Cratejoy: Discover Unique Subscription Boxes for Every Interest

Mystery Box

Mystery Box - Main image
Mystery Box - View 2Mystery Box - View 3Mystery Box - View 4Mystery Box - View 5Mystery Box - View 6
$19.8 $30 In stock

The My Paper Box Mystery Box is a one-time surprise filled with thoughtfully designed stationery. Each box includes at least 3 notepads and a diamond pen, plus additional paper goods. Most items are new or unreleased designs, with a few past favorites mixed in. No personalized items are included. Every box is different—that’s part of the fun.

Before you pay

Check the method and total at checkout.

When it ships

Allow for processing time as well as the journey to you.

Standard Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

Express Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

View policy
If you need a refund

Keep your order number and contact the store to start.

Please contact us for the refund processing timeframe before returning an item.

View policy
Delivery costs

Review the cost for your destination and chosen service.

Standard Shipping · United States: $0.00

Express Shipping · United States: $3.99

View policy
Returning an item

Check the return conditions before sending anything back.

United States · Return window (days after delivery): 30. Return method: By mail. Return postage: Seller pays.

View policy

Customer Reviews (5.0 / 5 · 5 reviews)

Avery ★★★★★

I wasn’t sure what I’d get, but the three notepads all have different paper textures that make writing feel fresh. The diamond pen has a nice weight to it and hasn’t skipped once.

Joshua T. ★★★★★

The diamond pen writes so smoothly, I’ve already used it more than the notepads. This mystery box really nailed the surprise factor without feeling like junk.

John M. ★★★★★

Opened it expecting a gamble, but the three notepads are thick and satisfying to write on, and that diamond pen glides really smoothly. Took me a couple of minutes to sort through all the extra paper goodies, but everything feels intentional and well-made.